Would you do this trade?

No don't do that deal...you won't win the saves category if you do. Your team is strong the way it is and Theriot would be on your bench. Adding Ichiro means you have to bench one of your other OF's. So you're losing 2 closers and not adding that much on offense. Reyes could be a fantasy stud if he gets healthy. Keep what you have and hope that Reyes is back to being a good fantasy player!